Issue Brief
House Bill 2005: Health Insurance
Regulation Reform
Background
Our health care system is the most
expensive in the world. Yet as a
system, it fails to come close to
providing the best health care in
the world.
Medical costs currently consume 16
percent of our national income and
are expected to grow to 20 percent
by 2015. This has become a heavy
economic burden that adds
significantly to the cost of
virtually every product and
transaction in our economy. Many
employers are trying to shed this
cost by shifting the cost of health
insurance to their employees or by
abandoning health insurance coverage
altogether. Thus, a growing
percentage of people living in the
United States are uninsured, while
health insurance companies continue
to make substantial profits.
Despite Medicare, the Veterans
Administration, and the Children’s
Health Insurance Program,
there are still approximately
800,000 adult Pennsylvanians, below
age 65, that do not have any health
insurance and are not eligible for
government-funded insurance.
Many access health care via
emergency rooms, which they utilize
when medical problems are acute. If
they suffer from a chronic disease,
often a medical professional does
not manage their treatment. The
un-insured often cannot fill their
prescriptions or, if they do, they
cannot afford to take prescription
drugs in the recommended dosages.
They are usually forced to pay
retail prices for both medical
treatment and medications which they
often cannot afford. When costs
pile up, many choose bankruptcy as
the way out.
House Bill 2005 would give the PA
Insurance Department increased
authority to regulate rates and
insurance products. The intent of
this legislation is to insure that
the price of insurance will only go
up as the cost of medical services
increases. Insurance companies
would be restricted in how much they
could spend on administration,
advertising, and profits, as
companies will be required to spend
85% of premium revenue on actual
medical care. Increased regulation
would also make it easier to shop
for insurance. All providers would
be required to sell a standard
policy so that people can more
easily compare rates.
It is also the intent of this bill that
insurance reform would ensure
that people have access to coverage
regardless of a pre-existing
condition. Medical history and
gender will no longer prevent people
from obtaining affordable coverage.
Instead, small businesses will pay
for their group policies based on a
“community rating” that takes into
account the average age of their
workforce and geography. This
community rating will enable small
employers to have less volatile
health care costs from year to
year.
Everyone
who cannot currently get affordable
insurance because of a pre-existing
illness or injury will benefit from
HB 2005, even people who are
purchasing
insurance individually. Increased
regulation will ensure that insurance
rates are not excessive, inadequate, or
unfairly discriminatory.
ELCA Policy Base
“ The one who had much did not have too
much, and the one who had little did not
have too little. (2 Corinthians 8:15)
“Government is intended to serve God’s
purposes by limiting or countering
narrow economic interests and promoting
the common good… We call for…appropriate
government regulatory reform so that
governments can monitor private sector
practices more effectively and
efficiently…”
(Sufficient, Sustainable Livelihood for
All, 1999)
“The prophetic voice of Jeremiah cried out
to the Israelites, ‘Why then has the
health of my poor people not been
restored?’” (8:22)
“As members of the ELCA, we support
equitable access for all people to basic
health care services… We recognize our
mutual responsibilities and guard
against the ways in which motivation to
maximize profit and to market health
care like a commodity jeopardizes health
and the quality of health care for all…
[and that] governments have the
obligation to provide leadership and
coordination in balancing competing
private and social interests in moving
toward the goal of equitable access to
health care.”
(Caring for Health: Our Shared Endeavor,
2003)
What You Can Do:
·
Visit, call, write and/or e-mail your
State Senator and tell them how
important access to health care for all
Pennsylvanians is to you. Tell them you
support HB 2005 and you
hope he or she will join you in support
and move it to the floor for a vote.
• Listen to the personal health care
struggles of people in your community
and communicate
the stories to policy makers and
the LAMPa office.
·
Join your local Pennsylvania Health
Access Network (PHAN) coalition (www.pahealthaccess.org)
and participate in the discussion on how
best to provide health care for all
Pennsylvanians. If a coalition does not
exist in your area, be a leading force
in creating one. You can call the
LAMPa office to help get you started.
May 2008